Category Archives: Book Reviews

Simplicius Simplicissimus: A picaresque tale of the Thirty Years War

 

Recently, I realized, as one does, that I did know as much about the Thirty Years War as I thought I should. I sought to rectify this by reading about the conflict (or as it turns out, series of conflicts) by doing some reading. Several different books were recommended, but when I found out that a classic fictional account was considered to be a realistic firsthand account of the war, I decided to read it.  The Adventures of Simplicius Simplicissimus by Hans Jakob Christoffel von Grimmelshausen is a mouthful of a title/author combination, but a relatively short read.  In the introductory notes in the Penguin edition (translated by J.A. Underwood), it is noted that this is a well known book in the German world.  Nevertheless, my German colleagues in academia had not heard of the book (or for that matter much about the Thirty Years War as, ahem, more recent wars dominate the history the curriculum in school).

The book was a good read for me for the mundane reason that the chapters are short (typically less than 4 pages), so it was a great pre-bedtime read because I could feel like I accomplished something by reading for a few minutes.  In short my episodic reading matched the episodic telling of the narrative.

The story follows the Simplicius. As a boy he runs away when a the Swedish army raids his family’s modest homestead in the Spessart, a low mountain range in Hesse and Bavaria. He lives in the woods for a period of time, is a fixture in the court of a Governor, finds himself on both sides of the war, becomes famous as the Hunstman of Soest, finds riches and loses them repeatedly, and struggles with demons both inner and outer.  He also discovers who his true father is in a scene the reminded me of Bill Pullman’s character in Spaceballs. My summary cannot do the book justice, but I do think that it was worth the read.

I will admit that I did not learn much about the ins and outs and what-have-yous of the Thirty Years War. One of the most remarkable things is that it is not clear at many points what side Simplicius finds himself on.  I think this is one of the biggest takeaways I had from the book. The armies that were fighting were, in a large part, separate from the people of the land they were fighting in.  They raided from peasants and villagers what they could, and the armies, from either “side”, were typically equal trouble for the citizenry.  Indeed, in one episode Simplicius goes to Switzerland, a land not involved in the war, and he remarks that it feels entirely different to be in a place where raids, conscription, and attack are not the order of the day.

Another takeaway I had was that the violence in the book was not as lurid as I expected.  The Thirty Years War has a reputation for its bloody savagery.  For sure there is violence and death to beat the band in the this book, but it is really a sidelight to the story.  Perhaps that should be the most shocking thing: the violence was not the remarkable aspect of the war. The violence was almost prosaic, even a pervasive in the ambient environment. That might be the most shocking finding for modern readers.

Book Review: The Final Solution by Michael Chabon

After finishing this book, I’m still not sure how I feel about it.  It was an enjoyable read and a short enough book that it didn’t feel like a chore to read.  I also feel like the author was trying to develop larger themes that did not quite make it across.

This book is about an aged detective coming out of retirement to solve one last case (all set against the English countryside in WWII).  Though it sounds like a noir plotline, it is nothing of the sort.  The exposition feels light, though the material it is dealing with is somewhat dark. The perspective of the narration changes throughout the novel in an interesting way. The detective keeps bees as a hobby and the local Anglican minister is an immigrant from South Asia married to an Englishwoman.

These are the kind of details that I feel should be important, and I am sure they were intended to be, but they did not make much of an impression on me.  Perhaps I didn’t read the text closely enough (it wouldn’t be the first time), or maybe the points made were a so on the nose that the larger themes didn’t coalesce for me.  I suppose both could be options.

On the other hand, there were some great passages in the book.  The scene of the old detective bee keeping was great passage, and the description of the the characters arriving in London during WWII was very thought provoking.  Beyond these, the description of how the countryside was affected by the war alone made the book worth reading.

Book Review: The Vulgar Streak by Wyndham Lewis

I’ve been meaning to put my musings on the books I read on this site for a while. In most instances it will be in areas where I am not an expert.

First off, the title refers to common thread in a person’s character that evokes the common (aka vulgar), or working class. In this case, it refers to mannerisms in the protagonist’s behavior.  It does not, as I was expecting, refer to a habit of exploding into profanity-laced tirades by a character.

Continue reading